PDA

View Full Version : Wisconsin politician proposes 1% tax on video games


Clipse
01-07-2008, 10:02 PM
Another year, another silly bill that'll probably end with taxpayers having to pay an overzealous state's legal bills. Wisconsin Senator Jon Erpenbach is proposing a bill that will raise a child's age to be considered an adult in the state's criminal court from 17 to 18, but the way he wants to pay for "driving up costs [in] counties that administer court procedures" is by placing a 1% tax on video games and video game consoles.

The Electronic Software Association obviously went straight to the battle chest with an eye-roll and a sigh. Joystiq received comment from ESA prez. Mike Gallagher (full statement after the break) where he says, "[The bill] unfairly burdens all Wisconsin consumers by imposing a double tax on video games and game consoles ... there is no public policy support for the bill: The fact is that national juvenile crime has decreased as video games have soared in popularity." If the Wisconsin legislators don't shoot this bill down, the judges will probably do it for them later -- Wisconsin taxpayers should prepare to foot the legal bills soon after.

[Thanks, Ed]

ESA full statement:

"This bill will stunt an industry that is growing in Wisconsin at over 11% per year and contributes more than $23 million to the state economy. It negatively impacts the hundreds of Wisconsin citizens whose jobs and families depend on the computer and video game industry. And, it unfairly burdens all Wisconsin consumers by imposing a double tax on video games and game consoles. Not only is it unconstitutional to discriminatorily target video games with a punitive tax, there is no public policy support for the bill: The fact is that national juvenile crime has decreased as video games have soared in popularity."
-- Michael D. Gallagher, president of the entertainment software association.

Source: Joystiq (http://www.joystiq.com/2008/01/07/wisconsin-politician-proposes-1-tax-on-video-games/)

deathbypig37x
01-08-2008, 12:38 AM
Source: Joystiq (http://www.joystiq.com/2008/01/07/wisconsin-politician-proposes-1-tax-on-video-games/)

I honestly think both sides are being overplayed...1% tax on all video games AND consoles? WTF?
Now, as ourageous as that seems to me, I don't think it would make much of a difference....so we pay $66 with all tax instead of $64....So we pay $5 more on consoles....I don't see how this would affect the individual. Jobs I understand would be threatened and such, but the bill isn't ridiculous. It's not like it will hold any ground anyway, I don't think much will result of this to be honest. ;)

Tussell
01-08-2008, 01:11 AM
Pfft... Fuck tha police!

Anyways, I'd have to agree with Death to some extent with this one. But when you think about it, it's a huge chunk of change at the end of the day.

Shadow
01-08-2008, 01:15 AM
Yeah, it is. I honestly don't see whats wrong with it. It's an extra couple of bucks for God sakes, and if it's all going towards a good cause, then why not?

Azeron
01-08-2008, 08:34 AM
Heh, over here there's a 19% tax on everything you buy, with the exception of food and books and some other things which only have 6% tax. It's just another way to redistribute wealth.
Yeah, it is. I honestly don't see whats wrong with it. It's an extra couple of bucks for God sakes, and if it's all going towards a good cause, then why not?
Careful now, once you accept a tax like that you're opening the door both for it to be increased and for it to be applied to other products as well.

codedigital
01-08-2008, 01:25 PM
I honestly think both sides are being overplayed...1% tax on all video games AND consoles? WTF?
Now, as ourageous as that seems to me, I don't think it would make much of a difference....so we pay $66 with all tax instead of $64....So we pay $5 more on consoles....I don't see how this would affect the individual. Jobs I understand would be threatened and such, but the bill isn't ridiculous. It's not like it will hold any ground anyway, I don't think much will result of this to be honest. ;)

Because we already pay sales tax on those items.

Is it going to be ok when we start getting taxed extra when we buy a cake?
Is it going to be ok when we start getting taxed extra to buy swimming trunks?
Is it going to be ok when we start getting taxed extra to buy kites?

NATERZ
01-08-2008, 02:12 PM
You know that 1% may not be much to one person or another. But the thing is that video game sales is outrageous. In 2006 there was a record $12.5 billion worth of sales. You do the math and tell me that the 1% isn't a $h1t ton of money overall!